Kicked out in '68 for protesting at Arizona State University, 78-year-old finally graduates
Alfredo Gutierrez is one of the most influential Latino leaders in Arizona. The 78-year-old has been recognized for a lifetime in public service. He was an Army private in Vietnam then a civil rights activist and state lawmaker. In the 1970 and 80s, he served as Arizona Senate majority leader.
But one accomplishment had eluded Gutierrez all these years: a college degree.
He was kicked out of Arizona State University in 1968 for leading student protests on campus.
Gutierrez kept his lack of a degree mostly to himself over the years, even as he encouraged young people to go to college and fought to increase college pathways for disadvantaged students. Now Gutierrez can finally say he, too, is a college graduate.
He graduated with a bachelor of liberal arts last week from ASU's College of Integrative Sciences and Arts.
Why did Alfredo Gutierrez go back to finish college?
One may wonder why, nearing 80, Gutierrez decided to finish college after already having accomplished so much in his life, including receiving an honorary doctorate from the same university. He certainly didn't need the diploma for his resume or to land a job.
"There are a couple of reasons," Gutierrez told the Arizona Republic, part of the USA TODAY Network. Over the years, Gutierrez spent a lot of time speaking to young people, especially Latinos, about the importance of staying in school and encouraging them to go to college. But the fact that he had never graduated himself gnawed at him.
"It seemed to me at 78 somewhat hypocritical that I had done that most of my life, and I didn't have the discipline, or didn't make the time, whichever the case may be, to go back and finish myself," Gutierrez said. "I just felt I had to do it."
His voice rings with a determination forged growing up in a hardscrabble mining town where Mexican Americans struggled against discrimination and segregation.
"I should have gotten a degree, so I'm going to go do it," Gutierrez declared.
And finally, graduating also seemed like a good way of getting back at the ASU officials who kicked him out nearly six decades ago.
"I just didn't want to let (them) get away with it," he said. "They just pushed me out, so the hell with it; I was going to go back and get the degree that was denied me, in my opinion."
Why was Alfredo Gutierrez kicked out of Arizona State University?
When he came home from Vietnam, Gutierrez enrolled at ASU on the GI Bill. He was the first person in his family to attend college.
He had grown up in a working-class family in Miami, an Arizona mining town east of Phoenix, and was drafted into the military at 17. During three years in the Army infantry, including a year fighting in Vietnam as a sharpshooter, Gutierrez said he realized that the soldiers he met who had college degrees were no smarter than him.
"They had no common sense, I thought, on how to deal with the realities that are imposed upon you in the Army in the '60s," Gutierrez said. "So the idea of going to college became agreeable to me. It was no longer the impossible barrier to me."
It was a time of large student protests on college campuses. The civil rights movement, anti-Vietnam War protests and the Chicano Movement championing Mexican-American identity all were taking place.
Inspired by Cesar Chavez, the farm worker advocate and civil rights leader, Gutierrez helped form the Mexican American Student Organization at ASU, which later became Movimiento Estudiantil Chicano de Aztlán, also known as M.E.Ch.A.
One of the organization's main causes became fighting for Mexican women, many undocumented, toiling in deplorable conditions for low pay at a laundry that washed bedding for sororities and fraternities on campus under contract with the university.
Gutierrez led protests demanding ASU pressure the laundry to improve working conditions and wages. When the school refused, Gutierrez helped lead a group of students who took over the president's office for several days.
In response, state troopers surrounded the building, the Arizona Board of Regents demanded the students be expelled, and the Legislature asked the governor to call up the National Guard, Gutierrez said.
"It was kind of crazy," Gutierrez said, pointing out similarities to the recent Israel-Hamas war protests at ASU and on other campuses.
Gutierrez said the university was determined to kick him out. He said he was accused of violating a student code of conduct the university rejiggered specifically to force him out. He was given a choice, he said: be expelled with no chance of returning or leave voluntarily with the opportunity to reapply for admission in the future.
"I chose to leave so I could come back," Gutierrez said.
But Gutierrez never went back.
He got married, had a baby and needed money to support his family.
"Life happened," Gutierrez said.
Decades of public service leadership in Arizona
Gutierrez went to California to work with Cesar Chavez organizing farmworkers. He also worked for Robert F. Kennedy's 1968 presidential campaign. He was at the Ambassador Hotel in Los Angeles the night Kennedy was shot on June 5, 1968.
After Kennedy's death, Gutierrez was among the first to receive a Kennedy Memorial Fellowship to spend 18 months training to pursue a career in politics, public service and social justice. The stipend allowed him to support his family, and the experience was life-changing. It put Gutierrez in contact with some of the day's most prominent and important social justice and civil rights leaders.
"I attended a number of seminars with some extraordinary people, went to Harvard for special programs and in D.C. met with some unbelievable folks," Gutierrez said. The people he met included U.S. Sens. Ted Kennedy and J. William Fulbright and political activist Ralph Nader.
In 1972, when Gutierrez was 27, he ran for the state Senate and won. Two years later, he was selected to serve as Senate majority leader. Gutierrez spent 14 years in the legislature, most of that time in leadership roles.
While in the Legislature, Gutierrez pushed for Arizona to finally join the Medicaid program. Since then, the Arizona system has provided health care to millions of low-income families and individuals.
After leaving office, the political consulting firm he co-founded, Jamieson and Gutierrez, helped pave the way for the construction of sports arenas in a downtrodden area of central Phoenix. Although the idea of using public money to build sports arenas was politically unpopular at the time, Gutierrez said he saw building the facilities as a way of revitalizing the city's economically depressed core.
Gutierrez also was instrumental in opening South Mountain Community College to serve students in predominantly Latino and Black neighborhoods in south Phoenix. He helped found Chicanos Por La Causa and Valle del Sol, two Latino organizations that provide social services to working-class families.
In the 2000s, Gutierrez helped lead grassroots campaigns against the 2010 immigration enforcement law known as SB 1070 and former Maricopa County Sheriff Joe Arpaio's immigration sweeps.
In 2014, Gutierrez was appointed to the governing board of the Maricopa Community Colleges. He stepped down as board president in 2018 after a fall caused a brain injury that temporarily affected his ability to walk and talk.
Then, in 2023, Gutierrez decided to return to ASU and complete his degree.
SB 1070:10 years after, what happened to Arizona's undocumented population?
Being welcomed back at ASU to complete novel, degree
Vanessa Fonseca-Chavez, an associate dean of inclusion and student success, was at her office on the ASU Tempe campus last fall when an academic adviser invited her to meet a prospective student.
The man wanted to talk about finishing his degree through the College of Integrative Sciences and Arts, which is designed to provide flexibility to nontraditional students returning to college at different stages in life.
He was an older gentleman Fonseca-Chavez did not recognize. She said she didn't think much of his age because the college receives many older students, and his name did not immediately ring a bell.
But during a short break, Fonseca-Chavez went back to her office and Googled Gutierrez's name. A long list of articles and entries appeared, highlighting his many achievements, which Gutierrez had not shared.
He was a political consultant and a migrant advocate in the 1990s and 2000s. In 2002, Gutierrez had run for governor. And more recently Gutierrez served as Maricopa County Community College District president.
His push for fair wages for Latino workers, health care for the poor, community college accessibility in south Phoenix, professional sports stadiums in downtown Phoenix, and protection of immigrant rights created institutional changes that have benefited millions of Arizona residents.
"Sir, you didn't tell me exactly who you were," Fonseca-Chavez recalled telling Gutierrez. "I told him I would be so honored to work with him."
Gutierrez told Fonseca-Chavez he was working on a novel set in a mining town in Arizona in the 1960s. The novel is based on Gutierrez's life growing up in Miami.
Fonseca-Chavez and Rafael Martinez, a professor of Southwest borderlands at Arizona State University, worked with Gutierrez on creating an independent study program based on the novel to earn the final credits he needed to finish his degree. Gutierrez had never written a novel. Fonseca-Chavez helped him develop characters, narrative flow and other literary devices.
The novel has been edited and will soon be sent to publishers.
Fonseca-Chavez said work with Gutierrez was humbling.
"Just knowing that at the time he stood up for Mexicanas who were working in the laundry at ASU in the 1960s — it's incredible that he stood up for them, and then the consequence of that was not being able to finish a degree," Fonseca-Chavez said.
Now, nearly 60 years later, he has.
Reach the reporter at [email protected].